I can play a warr in cov as a silver acct no issues except for HA (anyone can struggle w those even gold raid accts)
Sk i tend not to bother playing silver cause he struggles more
I have a general approach when using either tank (or a paly)
can he aggro, can he tank, can he survive (ill even consider can he dps<paly>), comfortably
If all those boxes are checked and kill times are similar (close), I'm set
For me there is no best
Its more like Yoda said , do or do not there is no try
I don't want to work harder, cut it close, squeak by, I either dominate or I don't anything less is crap
The whole well this one can aggro more (u either have aggro lock or u dont), means nothing to me
This one mitigates better..... If I can single heal preferably w a shaman and never med, not struggle and not just barely get by, Im set
If the pace is to my liking, what do I care that this one or that one can kill this or that mob a few seconds faster sometimes........
Probably like the Hodge Twins used to say "Do What evah da fuk ya wanna do" (look em up they rock)
In the end its not what everyone else likes its what YOU like