Halo 3s single player really is just halo 1 & 2 tacked together, the massive deja vu attack of the last mission really emphasised that for me. The multi player is good though, even if it seems alot like the other halos (i haven't tried or figured out forge yet though). At least the story didnt piss me off like halo 2 (I remember finishing hl ep1 around the same time, with yet another cliff hanger)
I like the look of the coop mode too (playing it on easy with my friend made me wish i hadn't bothered with normal mode, hiding like a pussy every time you get shot twice gets tedious).
At the end of the day though, I cant see why it deserves all the high scores, it really is just another shooter, something the was kinda lacking on consoles when the original came out, but now they seem 10 a penny.