Disclaimer: This is all back of the napkin and from memory. I might be wrong. Plus, kinda late and I’m sleepy…
Alright so you’re talking about a difference of 1 damage over a 37 delay. The most noticeable difference of that will be fully hasted. Let’s assume you always have a bard so you’re at something like 125% haste which puts you at a delay of like 17. Maybe 16, so we’ll use 16 just for illustration.
1 over 16 delay is a ratio increase of .063 so you’re trading that ratio for 3000 damage.
Now, you got all kinds of damage bonuses, crits, heroic stats that change both that and the proc damage. But let’s assume you proc at a rate of 1 proc per minute which is probably way low (base is like 2). So we’re probably overestimating your weapon damage and underestimating your proc damage. I didn’t look up resist rates for that proc so I’m just going to use one quarter of the damage (resist completely three out of four times on average). Which means I’m probably way underestimating your proc damage. We’ll call it 750 damage per minute.
I’m also not counting double attacks, ripostes, etc which would increase the value of your weapon damage and I’m assuming it’s all going to wash out since we’re doing fuzzy math anyway.
That said, the raw additional damage is 1 every 1.6 seconds. That means over the course of a minute you’re doing a raw damage increase of at least ~38 damage. versus 750 from the proc. There would have to be a LOT of additional bonuses or a LOT of resists on the proc to close that gap to where the 1 damage is better than the proc.
Again, napkin math, so I could be wrong. But this is why I’d probably pick the proc aug.