I've always thought the uber game guy from that thing was a fag, ever since I saw some MTV True Life "I'm a Gamer" special that featured him because of his perfect Pacman game, and he was decidedly NOT what is generally considered a gamer, and gave all gamers a bad name.
That aside though, I guess the documentary was really mis-leading. If you go to the site with whatever forum they talk about in the movie, they have a few sticky/announcement posts about it that claim it's completely the other way around. I don't know that I take those to be 100% correct either... and that one guy is still a complete douchefag.
It's kind of funny though how they have their "elite" acrade cabinet gamer crew and think they are the best of the best of gamers. They're not. It's just that no one gives two shits enough to play those games over and over for 3-5 years memorizing all the levels inside and out, when there are much, much better games on the market today that require real reactions and skills, instead of just level memorization. That's why people play multiplayer games today. Why PvP has appeals over PvE in MMOs. People are sick of just memorizing a level or how to deal with a predictable AI reaction when there's more out there to be had. These dumbass middle aged motherfuckers can't cope with that though.
But those guys all think they're some kind of gods. When they're really quite pathetic, mullet wearing, basement dwelling, socially awkward fucking... losers? Is that the right word there? I wanted to use nerds or geeks, but that's almost demeaning to the rest of us.
Either way, the movie and those people in it annoyed me to the point of wanting to just walk away from it a few times, but I stuck it out and it's interesting enough to be a worthwhile rental/Netflix pickup.