If you arent in current era raid gear, I'd be willing to bet everyone would slightly benefit from 1 piece at least, just because you're losing ~1k HEM for 3 slot 18/19 (which should now always be better), but its reaching the point of use whichever you get first and if you dont have the tbl gear, its not worth going out of your way to get it unless you have nothing else to do.
As an example, a melee dps going from blood-soaked to tbl for shoulder/finger would be trading: 10 luck, ~700 HP and ~600 EM on blood-soaked to pick up 21hdex and a melee proc (and thats just using Dire + RZ enhancement + 7dex proc aug).
Rangers are still wearing 2-3 pieces over current era raid gear though, and the only reason they arent also running gloves is because the raid glove focus finally beats the tbl glove focus by enough to matter.