I agree if that were the only thing I was dealing with (and believe me, I'm not trying to rag on the plugins...really!). Here's a story I can relate from last night. Griklor raid. Heavily boxed all around. For me, specifically: ENC, SK, MAG, CLR, SHM, and BST. All using CWTN. All of them in Vorpal mode. All of them set to the same raid MA. All except ENC with UseMelee on. SK and BST have SwitchWithMA turned on. All set to a CampRadius of 90. If there are other configurations, you are interested in knowing about, let me know. All have this defined in their events config (CLR doesn't call pet off):
How I handle Griklor running
INI:
[Griklor Retreats]
trigger=#*#Griklor lets out a tuneless whistle#*#
command=/multiline ; /pet back; /target clear; /timed 7 /attack off
Grik drops, first round of beat down, Grik hops back on the mount. It's the first drop and the MA switches over to the dervish in camp quickly. I do a quick check to make sure each of the characters isn't trying to auto follow Grik. MAG and SHM are in camp as I would hope. SK, BST, and CLR have to be reigned in. It takes a couple cycles of manually turning attack off and pulling them back to get them to redirect. I run three monitors with two characters each; the MAG/SHM are on the same monitor, I can see one of them (whichever happens to be up on that monitor) engaging the dervish.
Sometimes, but not often, I do forget to have SwitchWithMA on. But even when I fix it, it still happens. Eventually, I just pause the plugins for everyone as soon as Grik hops on the mount. And this presents a problem in that I really need the CLR active for heals and dealing with the dots. I guess what puzzles me most is why it's inconsistent. I almost never have to worry about the MAG or SHM. Often I have to worry about the other three with melee on. I've played with the /timed value (all from not having it up to a value of 10). The only thing I haven't tried yet is briefly pausing the plugin.
"i forget to have switchwithma on" that's probably half your problem --- the shm, ench, mag etc you can't turn this off, so they're always switching with the ma - the other problem is probably - if your ma regains a target because they took damage from something - then, of course, the assist toons are going to assist because they've been given a target. which is why i recommend clearing your target and then targeting yourself - so now they won't be re-given a target by your MA targetting something it is hit by.
also keep in mind, if for some reason you have some toons not in raid mode, and other toons in raid mode with raid assist assigned, you're going to have half toons trying to assist off of 1 person, and half toons running off of another.
you should consider adjusting your events. there are many many many people who run these events with the plugins.
the switchwithma thing doesn't just "decide not to work" - but i'm happy to take a look if you can create a repeatable situation (that i can test, not in a raid with multi groups etc) where switchwithma doesn't clear your target if your MA clears and/or targets themselves.
it sounds like some modifying of how you're doing things will fix you up.
but a passive-aggressive (intended or otherwise) "or plugins" is so unhelpful to anyone i can't emphasize it enough.
any time you're looking specifically for a toon to not do the things they're trying to do - assist someone, do moving, casting buffing etc - like you mentioned pausing them would be the correct thing to do. for the melee toons you can also just manual mode them and clear their target / target themselves until it is time that you want them to start doing things automatically again.
being able to quickly manage your team is just as important as the tools that they are using for their automation. I would consider setting up some additional hotkeys to have everyone go manual mode, and possibly target themselves - this would allow your cleric to still heal, but since everyone is now in manual mode, with their target cleared, they wouldn't be chasing anyone or attacking anyone and would require you to pause anyone.
hopefully some other folks can share their events with you, and resolve your issues/concerns.
but again, if you're able to reliably replicate the issue in a setting that is reproducible, i'm happy to take a look at it - because if your designated ma has no target, or is targeting themselves, and you have switchwithma on or you are one of the classes that you can't turn on switchwithma - you absolutely shouldn't still be on the mob.
I would personally leave switchwithma on full time, and only toggle it off / turn it off when you need/want to
/cwtnra switchwithma on
good luck